Saturday, September 27, 2014

Product Developement

Customer High Level requirement is that they require a UAV System that weighs less than 80 pounds for a two person lift and set up (Avalanche rescue teams always work in teams of no less than two for safety) (Mount Washington Avalanche Center, 2014) and deployment from a transportation unit that is rigid, can sustain falls from a height of 4 feet (normal carry height), can sustain a shock from a height of 4 feet onto rigid terrain in temperatures of -30F.  User requires that transport case can fit all components such as UAV, controller, power modules, infrared cameras, night vision camera in a fashion that will not allow the components to be damaged by the case or by each other should fall occur. The user also requires UAV transport case to have incorporated tie down supports so that transport can be strapped to snowmobile skid and secured. It is not a requirement that the case must be able to be pulled behind a snowmobile on it’s own.  User requires case incorporate antiskid coating to prevent case from sliding down slippery slopes as well at an attachment point to anchor case when not attached to skid.

I would like to match a UAV system with the disaster response of avalanche victim retrieval. After an avalanche it is possible that search and rescue facilities have been damages, search vehicles cannot get out, unfavorable weather prohibiting rescue personnel and vehicles to be deployed. I’ve chosen to use a product similar to the Alliance single rotor, 2-stroke gas engine for this scenario because of its abilities. It has a long on station time perfect for FLIR and night vision that search and rescue requires. This platform is also tested in harsh conditions, high winds, and high altitudes (Homeland Surveillance and Electronics LLC, 2014).
This system is currently available as an all-inclusive package to include the carrying case, power supply, as well as ground station and hand help remote capabilities. This platform is already available and I am only looking at the aspects of transportability, support equipment, and cost. Time frame for design, testing, evaluation, etc. should be able to be completed within a 6-month timeframe, as there are no aerodynamic aspects to these three factors.
Because of the nature of the environment is cold, windy, and wet. The case is required to house all of the components, be transportable, be in a hardened case, and weigh less than 80 pounds. Cases such as those made by Pelican are designed to be waterproof, dustproof, able to withstand extreme heat and cold, as well as have options for custom cut high impact resistance foam. For this to be successful I would,
1.     Start with the weight of the craft and all of its components required for the     specific mission.
2.     Subtract that weight from 80 to get available case weight numbers.
3.     Design a case less than 80 pounds that can be carried by two people.
4.     Design a case that allows for the craft to be the most intact for quick deploy ability and less assembles time.
5.     Design a case that shall be secured quickly to a snowmobile skid if necessary
6.     Design a case that shall have secure and separated cutouts for each component that would in the event of a drop, keep contents secured and safe from damaging other components.
7.     Design a case with antiskid exterior that when placed on a moderate incline of 25 degrees on ice/snow will not slip away.
8.     Design case with incorporated tether point so emergency crews can attach an anchor should terrain be too much for exterior texture.
9.     Design a case that shall be durable incase of a fall from a height of 4 feet or
10.  Design a case that shall withstand drops in temps down to-30 degrees at 4 feet because of avalanche prone locations.

TESTING REQUIREMNTS
1.     Inspect the transportation case for suitable number of cutouts
2.     Test fit of UAV into the case
3.     Test fit of components (FLIR, Controls, power source, night vision, etc.) into case cutouts
4.     Test tie down locations (these locations would be no more than integrated low spots in the plastic of the case to ensure tie downs do not slip forward or backward when being transported by snowmobile).
5.     Verify case can withstand a drop from 4 feet onto a simulated surface such as rigid ice, in an environment of -30 degrees.
6.     Verify case is not damaged after a drop of 4 feet on rigid surface at -30F.
7.     Verify contents are not damaged after a drop from 4 feet onto rigid surface at -30F.
8.     Verify that case and contents weight less than 80 pounds
9.     Verify that on a grade covered in ice and snow of 25 degrees or less that the “non-skid” exterior holds case in place with and without UAV inside.
10.  Verify that incorporated anchor point is easily accessible.

The type of development would be to incorporate an already existing system such as a predetermined UAV and all of its accoutrements. The development would be of the transportation method to which an existing case with rough specifications to what is needed. The first action would be concept design, to identify a case that is rigid and is large enough to hold all of the required contents. Second would be to research different materials that are known to stand up to shock and extreme cold.  Examine materials that would be best for non-skid materials and that would remain intact with case materials as well as stand up to the cold. Design a case of rough specification from acceptable materials. Cut foam inserts to exacting specifications for UAV and it’s components. We would then build a prototype case from determined materials, covered with determined non-skid, and fitted with cut foam filled with ballast of the same form and weight of actual UAV and components outfitted with accelerometers to measure forces. Case would first be tested in controlled environment such as a deep freeze with capabilities of -30F. Case would be dropped on various (ice-like) surfaces from a height of no more than 4 feet from every conceivable angle to simulate side, front, corners, and etc. impacts. After no less than one thousand drops from every angle the case and its contents would be examined after each drop to check for damage. Two people to help simulate real life situations would perform each drop. After controlled testing was complete the product would be taken into the actual environment that it would be used. Search and rescue personnel would be issued the cases filled with ballast to assist with testing in simulated scenarios. After thorough testing, reevaluation, and further modification the case would go into final testing and development. After which time the case would be used by the customer for final modification and then put into production. Support of the case would be no more than replacement parts such as hinges, handles, foam, and seals and could be locally procured. Estimated development time following the initial concept would be one year. I chose this product because it contained many variables such as extreme cold, lasting rigidity, anchor system, tie down system, etc.



References
Homeland Surveillance and Electronics LLC. (2014). Alliance Twin Piston Gas Powered UAV Helicopter Key Specifications UAV.  http://www.hse-uav.com/alliancehd_uav_specs.htm

Mount Washington Avalanche Center. (2014). Search & Rescue » Mount Washington Avalanche Center. http://www.mountwashingtonavalanchecenter.org/search-rescue/

Sunday, September 21, 2014

The particular mission that I am discussing is the use of UAV for search and rescue missions. Search and rescue is a broad mission that operated all over the world, in every condition, and in every environment. Missions such as these require a host of different techniques and platforms such as fixed wing, and VTOL aircraft. Search and rescue missions require aircraft that can fly slowly at low altitudes as well as high speed, high altitude surveillance aircraft that can scan large sections much quicker than searchers on the ground (Handwerk, 2013).
                  A Texas base group called EquuSearch utilizes a Spectra Drone; a small propeller craft that can be hand launched and flies at an altitude of around 400 feet. It is equipped with a camera and relays photos, videos, and coordinates back to a ground controller that can interpret and dispatch rescuers to marked locations. This group has been under fire by the FAA and grounded the volunteer organization because under current guidelines, UAVs and remotely operated aircraft cannot be utilized for business and profit. The organization argues that they are not a for profit business and that they have been overly successful at finding missing persons in less time than it would take people on the ground. The group continues to fight the FAA and has filed a lawsuit. This discusses one area where UAV use is used in a specified area, low altitude fixed wing surveillance. However, legally the group is no longer in operation until the FAA concerning drone use for profit releases the new guidance (Subbaraman, 2013).
                  A second use for unmanned aircraft for search and rescue are VTOL aircraft; better know as rotor drones such as helicopters, octocopters, quadracopters, etc. Craft such as the Draganflyer X4-ES helicopter was used last year in a remote area of the woods in freezing conditions. After unsuccessful attempts by a manned search and rescue helicopter, a Draganflyer with a similar FLIR as the manned helicopter was able to find heat signatures of the man in the last general area that signals of his cell phone were used. Because this small drone was able to meticulously navigate at low altitudes in the dark, the whereabouts of the man were sent back to rescue crews who were able to get in and save the mans life. Missions such as this that may be too dangerous (flying at night, in treacherous conditions, at very low altitudes in wooded areas), by manned aircraft, can safely be conducted with drones such as the X4-ES. Because this type of search and rescue mission was operated out of Canada, by the police and not under the rule of the FAA, there was no red tape and a life was saved. Canada does not operated under the same limitations as the US in terms of UAV use (Franzen, 2013).
                  The third use for UAVs in search and rescue missions comes in the form of drone use for search and rescue in mines. Search and rescue efforts inside of mines can sometimes be too dangerous for manned operations and is better suited for small aircraft such as quad rotor aircraft. Other implications with mine search and rescue missions are that other humans cannot always access the miners in question. Drones can more easily locate the miners and transmit any kind of correspondence whether it is health statuses, oxygen levels or other potentially hazardous gas levels (University of Kwazulu Natal, 2013).
                  Benefits of unmanned aircraft for search and rescue missions are immense. Using unpiloted aircraft for these types of situations takes out the risk of human life in scenarios where the search and rescue efforts are in high altitude mountainous terrain where whether and elements can be a factor to pilots. Searches that cover large search areas that may take days, weeks, months can use drones for the “dull” factor where streaming media can be investigated by crews on the ground and not by a flight crew that might be tired worried about things such as suitable landing in an emergency situation.
                  Legal implications such as the ones listed above are what restrain companies like EquuSearch from assisting with search efforts. Until laws are passed outlining suitable and legal uses for UAV’s, there is a potential that lives could be lost from not using resources such as the Spectra Drone to located injured or missing individuals. Ethical challenges that are faced that tie into search and rescue missions could be as simple as a drone on a search and rescue mission for someone and coming across a field of marijuana in the middle of a farmer’s cornfield. Or flying over a house on the way to a certain area and capturing a nude pool party on video inadvertently. The use of drones for search and rescue missions, if used correctly could greatly improve the chances of finding lost or hurt people as well as saving valuable resources such as police officers from searching on foot.

References
Franzen, K. (2013, May). Canadian mounties claim first person's life saved by a police drone | The Verge.
 http://www.theverge.com/2013/5/10/4318770/canada-draganflyer-drone-claims-first-life-saved-search-rescue
Handwerk, B. (2013, December). 5 Surprising Drone Uses (Besides Amazon Delivery). http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2013/12/131202-drone-uav-uas-amazon-octocopter-bezos-science-aircraft-unmanned-robot/
Subbaraman, N. (2013, May). FAA Search-and-Rescue Drone Suit Could Have Widespread Impact - NBC News.
              http://www.nbcnews.com/tech/innovation/faa-search-rescue-drone-suit-could-have-widespread-impact-n87776

University of Kwazulu Natal. (2013, December). New UKZN-Developed Technology to Aid Mining Search and Rescue Missions.  http://www.ukzn.ac.za/news/2013/12/01/new-ukzn-developed-technology-to-aid-mining-search-and-rescue-missions

Saturday, September 6, 2014

The need for better separation practices among civil UAS operators is a growing concern in the US. While the actual number is hard to pin down, the monetary figure that is researches is a growth of 1400% in the civil UAV sector alone. With a rise such as this, it is expected that the skies will be much more dense with UAV use. The problem with the usage now and the projected usage is the future is the lack of air traffic control (ATC) following, locating, and communication options (Song, 2013). While the FAA is still hard at work to iron out the details of a UAV flight policy for civil use, the number continues to grow.
Currently there are very few “authorized” UAVs in the air and among those, many are operating out of their scope and conducting illegal operations such as profiting from the data collection. Even those who are granted an FAA Certificate of Authorization (COA), sometimes use it incorrectly. One good story about this is the case of the beer delivery drone in Wisconsin, a brewery was using an octocopter to deliver cases of beer to ice fisherman far out on the lack in ice shacks. The FAA was not supportive and shut the operation down (Kelly, 2014).
Separation being the issue there are some companies that offer products in the line of Sense and Avoidance Display Systems (SAVDSS) for UAV operators. Unlike manned aircraft that are subject to Visual Flight Rules (VRF) and that in most civil aircraft aren’t equipped with Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance systems (TCAS) transponders.  Without the pilot, VFR is not normally an option but with the SAVDSS system it will put systems such as; detecting and tracking airborne traffic in relation to the particular UAV, evaluating and prioritizing collision potential, features that algorithmically generate audible and visual alerts for safe separation and collision, and system recommendation for flight path changes to avoid collisions (SAVDS, 2013). This type of collision avoidance system is great for the user but still leaves a critical aspect out of the loop, ATC.
Companies such as SRC are creating Ground Based See and Avoid Stations (GBSS) that would allow ATCs to monitor and track UAVs in the same manner as the operators. With new legislation on the horizon for the rising demand of civil UAV use, it will be paramount to have systems such as the GBSS that can asses horizontal and well as vertical volume areas to track all types and sizes of UAVs. This system will allow an altitude breakdown of each craft and through the use of hundreds of land based sensors it will be able to determine size, type, speed, etc (SRC, 2012). UAVs are categorized in weight classes and currently under FAA COA regulations the largest UAVs that can be operated in civil airspace are 25 pounds or category 2 and below (Bernard, n.d.).
Much like manned aircraft, companies are now producing transponder systems specifically for UAS applications in order to better equip ATC with tracking capabilities while in ATC controlled airspace. NextGen Transponders are currently incorporating their ADS-B ONE systems into unmanned aircraft which is said to be compliant of the new FAA Unmanned regulations (NextGen, 2014).


References
Bernard, J. (n.d.). Small UAV Command, Control and Communication Issues. ieeexplore.ieee.org.ezproxy.libproxy.db.erau.edu/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=4450038
Kelly, H. (2014). Beer-delivery drone grounded by FAA - CNN.com.  http://www.cnn.com/2014/01/31/tech/innovation/beer-drone-faa/
NextGen. (2014). NextGen UAS Transponders | UAV Transponders. http://www.nextgenuastransponders.com/
SAVDS. (2013). SAVDS: Sense And Avoid Display System.  http://savds.com/aboutus.html
Song, X. (2013). Fly the Automated Skies: Drones and the Rise of the Civilian UAV Sector | DataFox. http://www.datafox.co/blog/fly-the-automated-skies-drones-and-the-rise-of-the-civilian-uav-sector/

SRC. (2012). Page Not Found | SRC, Inc. http://www.srcinc.com/pdf/60-GBSAA